Discussion Category:  Melting Point Apparatus

Tolerance of Calibration standards

I would like to know to what is the acceptance tolerance limit for the calibration of 4-nitrotoluine cuz i have achieved 51.9 and dipholacetic acid i got 147.2 is it okay? what is the range for them? standards are from Buchi and expired date is sep'2013

Its an urgent issue for me cuz for 4-nitrotoluine its written 52.3 +_  0.2 and rest are same..

let me know

avatar placemark

Asked by

shahed
Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
Sarah T

Your value should fall within the quoted range on the standard i.e. 52.1 - 52.5 so you are just outside the accepted limits. Without using standards that are within date you are not able to say whether it is the instrument or the sample that is at fault.

Are all the standards you have tried out of range and if so by how much?


Sarah Talbot BSc MSc MRSC

Method development and laboratory equipment sourcing specialist  
Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
shahed

Thanks for the reply.  As i hae mentioned that standards that has been used are within the exp date i.e. Sep'2013.

Again for i have got the result which is

4-Nitrotoluene:                    51.9
Diphenyl acetic acid:        147.1
Caffeine:                             236.5
Potassium nitrate:            334.3

First two i guess out of the limit. How can i solve the problem?

Model : M565 Melting Point    S/N : 1000105019

Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
Sarah T

Have you calibrated or are you just running the standard substances as samples?


Sarah Talbot BSc MSc MRSC

Method development and laboratory equipment sourcing specialist  
Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
Sarah T

If you have not calibrated you need to do so and enter the quoted values for your standard substances during the calibration procedure as per the instructions in the manual.


Sarah Talbot BSc MSc MRSC

Method development and laboratory equipment sourcing specialist  
Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
shahed

I have calibrated the instruments as per the instructions in the manual and this data is taken after the calibration.

Thats why i am not sure whether its instrument calibration fault or the substances. However the instrument is new and substances also fresh which cam with the instrument.

Plz let me know how to solve the problem.

Note : substances standard deviation is within  +/- 0.2 °C  range but generate the above mentioned results.

4-Nitrotoluene:                    51.9
Diphenyl acetic acid:        147.1
Caffeine:                             236.5
Potassium nitrate:            334.3

 

Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
Sarah T

If the instrument has performed a complete calibration there would not seem to be a problem as the calibration will not go to completion if the instrument perceives there to be an issue with any of the standards. If you entered 52.3 as the value for the 4-nitrotoluene it must have been within the +/- 0.2 or the machine would not have complted the calibration and the same applies to all the other standards.

I think that the instrument is working properly and do not think there is a problem. Do you have the verification set shown in the manual? If so run those and see what results you get.


Sarah Talbot BSc MSc MRSC

Method development and laboratory equipment sourcing specialist  
Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
rderickson

I imagine you are an experienced chemist. However, are you preparing the samples in accordance to the USP guidlines. Certainly the use of expired standards can be problamatic. The temperatures for the compounds you referenced sounds right. Provided you are following a method your results should be consistent.

Roger

Report this Post
avatar placemarkReply by
shahed

Dear Mr. Roger

Thanks for your reply.  As i have already mentioned that, its a new instrument and the melting point standards has came with the instrument, which is valid till sep'2013.

But the referrence tempurature is not obtained which should have been for up to 250 °C is  +/- 0.2 °C and for 250 °C to 400 °C  is +/- 0.3 °C.

Basically its not obtained as per described.

Is there any solution. And also results is consistent.

Report this Post

Page 1 of 1